Summary
This essay totally criticizes “the report concerning the theses” which was posted on 25 December, 2014 to RIKEN.
I wish provoking the controversy could be avoidable, but it is about time that we, the students who learn life science, show how reasonably we can discuss the STAP affair.
This essay is intended to become a standard for the inspection of scientific misconduct, especially when it arouses serious social problems. Using only official resources, the research process of the STAP cell is closely reconstructed. The inspection experiment will be evaluated from the other viewpoint. Through the work I conclude that Ms. Obokata have contaminated materials with ES cell on purpose, in spite of it, I deny her responsibility for it.
If you truly hope to put an end to STAP affair, you have to reflect on your understanding of scientific research and its misconduct.
